S Tier

VoidfishEndgame MythicVoidfish is the most-captioned rare-class fish in Pull a Lucky Fish. Community runs treat it as the top-end pull for the index.

A Tier

Prism FishMid LatePrism Fish sits in the rare tier. Its island income is solid for mid-game players who upgrade rods early.Alien FishLate ProgressionAlien Fish is a rare-class pull. It rewards players who commit to a high-luck rod and train their fishing skill.

B Tier

Puffer FishRisk / RewardPuffer Fish is a higher-risk pull. The encounter is faster than a starter catch but the reward jumps noticeably.

C Tier

CodfishStarterA reliable starter fish with low island income but high availability.Colorless FishStarterColorless Fish is the most common pull. It's a quick source of starter income and a good way to learn the cast cadence.SunfishStarterSunfish is a calm starter pull. Use it to fill out your island before chasing rare classes.DolphinStarterDolphin is captioned as a common starter pull. Decent island income for the cost of casting.